Restore

Tic-Tac-Toe Marriage: A Game Neither Spouse Can Win

The back of a couple sitting in front of a board that says "Tic-Tac Toe Marriage"

By Randy and Debbie Stroman

In 1983, a science-fiction thriller called WarGames, starring Matthew Broderick, introduced audiences to a frightening possibility. What if a computer designed to protect the United States couldn’t distinguish between playing a game and starting a nuclear war?

The story follows David Lightman, a teenage computer enthusiast who accidentally gains access to a powerful military computer known as WOPR (War Operation Plan Response). Believing he has discovered a computer gaming system, David begins playing what he thinks is a harmless game called Global Thermonuclear War. What he doesn’t realize is that the computer is connected to America’s nuclear defense system, and the game he has started could trigger an actual war.

The computer’s artificial intelligence, nicknamed Joshua, has been programmed to analyze strategies and determine how to win. But as the situation spirals toward disaster, David realizes that the answer isn’t finding a better strategy to defeat the computer. The answer is teaching Joshua something about the nature of the game itself.

He introduces Joshua to a simple childhood game: tic-tac-toe.

Joshua begins playing against itself, running through game after game, exploring every possible move and countermove. Eventually, it discovers something remarkable. When both players make the best possible moves, neither can win. Every game ends in a draw.

Joshua then applies that same lesson to the nuclear-war scenarios it has been calculating. No matter which side strikes first or how the other retaliates, the outcome is devastating. There is no meaningful victory.

The computer finally reaches a conclusion that has become one of the most memorable lines in the movie:

“A strange game. The only winning move is not to play.”

What does a forty-year-old movie about nuclear war have to do with marriage? Perhaps more than we would like to admit.

The Game We Play in Marriage

Think about the last disagreement you had with your spouse. Perhaps it began with something relatively small. A careless comment, an unmet expectation, a forgotten responsibility, or a tone of voice that communicated disrespect.

Your spouse made a move you didn’t appreciate, so you made one of your own.

Maybe your husband spoke harshly, so you responded with sarcasm. He felt disrespected and withdrew from the conversation. You interpreted his silence as rejection, so you became more critical. He became defensive, and before long, what started as a simple disagreement turned into an emotional standoff.

Or perhaps your wife has been distant and less affectionate. You feel rejected, so you stop pursuing her. She notices your lack of interest and becomes even more distant. You tell yourself that you’ll start showing affection when she starts responding to you again. Meanwhile, she’s waiting for you to demonstrate that you genuinely care.

Both spouses are waiting for the other to make the next healthy move.

And both believe they have a perfectly reasonable explanation for their behavior.

“I wouldn’t talk to you that way if you didn’t treat me that way.”

“I’ll apologize when you admit what you did.”

“I’ll start meeting your needs when you start meeting mine.”

“I’ll be kind when you start showing me some respect.”

Sound familiar?

This is marital tic-tac-toe. One unhealthy move invites another. Every response is calculated according to what the other person has done, and each spouse becomes increasingly convinced that the responsibility for changing the relationship belongs to the other.

The problem is that you cannot win in marriage by making your spouse lose.

Unlike a childhood game, however, the consequences of this competition are not erased when someone clears the board. Hurtful words leave memories. Emotional withdrawal creates distance. Repeated retaliation damages trust. And every round makes the next one easier to play, but more devastating.

Eventually, couples can become so focused on proving who is right that they forget they are supposed to be on the same team.

When Being Right Becomes More Important Than Doing Right

There is an interesting account in Judges 15 that reveals just how destructive retaliation can become.

Samson had experienced betrayal and mistreatment at the hands of the Philistines. His response was to retaliate. The Philistines then retaliated against him, and Samson responded again. What began as a personal grievance escalated into an increasingly destructive conflict.

When the men of Judah confronted Samson about his actions, he offered a remarkably simple explanation.

“As they did to me, so I have done to them.” (Judges 15:11, NKJV)

Think about that statement for a moment.

Samson didn’t explain why his actions were righteous. He didn’t describe how his response would bring peace or resolve the conflict. His justification was simply that someone else had done something to him first.

How often do we use that same reasoning in marriage?

We excuse our anger because our spouse was disrespectful. We justify our silence because our spouse was critical. We defend our dishonesty because our spouse overreacts. We withhold kindness because our spouse hasn’t earned it.

And somewhere along the way, we begin believing that another person’s unhealthy behavior gives us permission to behave in unhealthy ways ourselves.

But consider this question: when did your spouse’s behavior become the standard for your behavior? As followers of Christ, our standard isn’t established by how someone treats us. It is established by God’s Word.

Romans 12:17 instructs us not to repay evil for evil. A few verses later, Paul writes, “Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good” (Romans 12:21, NKJV). That instruction doesn’t suddenly become irrelevant because the person who hurt us happens to be our spouse.

Your husband may have been wrong in the way he spoke to you. Your wife may have been wrong in the way she responded. Their behavior may need to be acknowledged, addressed, and changed. But their wrongdoing does not make your wrongdoing right. You can be completely right about what your spouse did and still be completely wrong in how you respond.

And even if you successfully prove your spouse was wrong, what have you accomplished if the conflict remains unresolved and your relationship continues to suffer? Winning the argument is not the same as winning in marriage.

Hosea: A Different Way to Respond

One of the most extraordinary pictures of covenant love in Scripture is found in the book of Hosea.

God instructed the prophet Hosea to enter a marriage that would become a living illustration of His relationship with Israel. Hosea’s wife, Gomer, was unfaithful, just as Israel had repeatedly turned away from God to pursue other gods.

Imagine the humiliation, disappointment, and emotional pain associated with that kind of betrayal. Hosea had every human reason to feel rejected and wronged. Yet in Hosea 3:1, God instructed him to love his wife again despite her unfaithfulness.

The significance of this instruction is not that Gomer’s behavior was acceptable. It wasn’t. Nor does the story suggest that betrayal is insignificant or that restoring a broken relationship requires pretending nothing happened.

The remarkable lesson is that Hosea’s decision to obey God was not made conditional upon Gomer’s decision to do what was right. God did not tell Hosea to become unfaithful because Gomer had been unfaithful. He called Hosea to demonstrate a different kind of love—a love that reflected God’s own covenant faithfulness.

Hosea could not make Gomer repent. He could not control her decisions or guarantee the outcome of their relationship. But he could decide whether his own actions would be governed by her behavior or by God’s instruction. And that is where this ancient story becomes profoundly relevant to our marriages.

Too often, we approach change as a negotiation. We tell our spouse what we need them to do, and then we make our willingness to change dependent upon their compliance.

“If you stop criticizing me, I’ll stop withdrawing.”

“If you start showing me respect, I’ll start treating you with kindness.”

“If you become more affectionate, I’ll start paying attention to your needs.”

On the surface, these statements may sound reasonable. After all, marriage should involve mutual love, respect, and responsibility. Both spouses should be willing to change unhealthy behavior. But there is a fundamental problem with making our obedience conditional.

When we require our spouse to change before we will do what is right, we have given them control over our obedience to God.

Hosea demonstrates another way.

Rather than asking, “What must Gomer do before I will obey God?” his story challenges us to ask, “What is God asking me to do, regardless of what my spouse chooses?”

That is not weakness. It is a profound expression of spiritual strength.

It is also important to understand that Hosea received a specific prophetic assignment from God. His story should never be used to pressure someone to tolerate abuse, excuse ongoing betrayal, or remain in danger. Biblical love does not eliminate the need for truth, accountability, repentance, or healthy boundaries. Sometimes doing what is right requires confronting destructive behavior and taking necessary steps to establish safety.

The lesson is not that we must accept everything our spouse does. The lesson is that we remain responsible for doing what is right, even when someone else is doing what is wrong.

Humility Changes the Game

If retaliation keeps the game going, humility is what gives us the ability to stop.

That may sound simple, but humility is one of the most challenging qualities to practice in marriage, especially when we believe we have been wronged.

Pride tells us we must defend ourselves, prove our point, and make certain our spouse understands exactly how wrong they have been. Pride insists that making the first healthy move would somehow reward our spouse’s bad behavior or suggest that we were the one at fault.

Humility approaches the situation differently. Philippians 2:3–5 teaches us to reject selfish ambition and conceit, value others, consider their interests, and adopt the mindset of Christ.

Notice that Paul doesn’t tell us to practice humility only when others deserve it. He points us toward the example of Jesus, whose humility was rooted in obedience to the Father rather than the behavior of the people around Him.

In marriage, humility is not admitting you were wrong when you weren’t. It is not surrendering your voice, ignoring an offense, or accepting mistreatment. Humility is the willingness to make the right move, even when your spouse hasn’t.

Sometimes that means choosing a gentle answer when your spouse speaks harshly. Sometimes it means initiating a difficult conversation rather than withdrawing. Sometimes it means acknowledging your part in a conflict without insisting that your spouse acknowledge theirs first.

And sometimes it means saying, “I love you, and I want us to resolve this. But the way we are speaking to each other isn’t healthy. Let’s take some time to talk this over with God and return to this conversation when His wisdom allows us to work together.”

Humility doesn’t mean avoiding the problem. It means refusing to make the problem worse.

There is another important distinction here. We must be careful not to turn humility into another strategy for controlling our spouse. If our thinking becomes, “I’ll be kind so my spouse will finally do what I want,” we haven’t really stopped playing tic-tac-toe. We’ve simply changed our strategy.

True humility says, “I will do what is right because it is right, not because I can guarantee how you will respond.”

That doesn’t mean our behavior has no influence. Romans 2:4 teaches that God’s goodness leads people toward repentance. Kindness, patience, and humility can create an environment where defensiveness decreases and hearts become more open to change.

But influence is not control. We can create an opportunity for change without possessing the power to make someone change. Our responsibility is obedience. The other person’s response remains their responsibility.

Stop Playing and Start Working Together

So how do we stop playing marital tic-tac-toe when we’ve become accustomed to responding to every unhealthy move with one of our own?

It begins with recognizing that the person sitting across from us is not an opponent we are trying to beat. Genesis 2:24 describes marriage as two becoming one flesh. That means our spouse isn’t someone we are supposed to defeat. We are joined together in a covenant relationship designed for unity, mutual care, and shared purpose. When one of you loses, you both lose, no matter who “won” the current round.

When we treat our spouse as the enemy, we begin fighting against the very relationship God has called us to protect.

The next time you find yourself in a conflict, consider a different approach.

First, recognize the game. Pay attention to the moment when your thinking shifts from solving the problem to defending yourself or retaliating. Ask yourself whether your next response will help resolve the conflict or simply provoke another unhealthy move.

Second, take responsibility for your own behavior. Instead of focusing exclusively on what your spouse needs to change, ask God to reveal what He is asking of you. Perhaps you need to soften your tone, listen more carefully, acknowledge an offense, or apologize for the way you responded. Your spouse’s responsibility does not cancel yours.

Third, choose humility over the need to win. You don’t have to agree with your spouse’s perspective to treat them with dignity. You can communicate truth without attacking. You can express hurt without retaliating. You can maintain a necessary boundary without becoming unkind.

Finally, invite your spouse to work with you rather than against you. Instead of saying, “If you would just stop doing that, we wouldn’t have this problem,” try saying, “I don’t like what is happening between us. I know we both have things we need to work on, and I want us to find a better way forward together.”

That simple change moves the conversation away from assigning blame and redirects it towards solving the problem. It doesn’t guarantee an immediate resolution. Your spouse may not respond the way you hope. Some patterns require time, accountability, and outside help to change. But you have made a decision that can begin changing the direction of the relationship.

You have stopped contributing another unhealthy move to an already unhealthy game.

The Only Winning Move

At the conclusion of WarGames, the computer named Joshua finally understands what the humans have been desperately trying to teach it. Some contests cannot produce a meaningful victory. The pursuit of winning can become the very thing that guarantees defeat.

Marriage is not a game of tic-tac-toe, but far too many couples approach conflict as though it were. One spouse hurts the other. The other retaliates. Each waits for the other to change, and both become convinced that they are justified in withholding the very things their marriage needs most.

When love becomes conditional, kindness becomes negotiable, and respect becomes something to be earned rather than something we are responsible for demonstrating, the relationship suffers.

God’s way is better.

Hosea reminds us that our faithfulness to God does not have to be determined by another person’s faithfulness to us. Paul reminds us that evil is not overcome by more evil, but by good. And Jesus demonstrates the humility that makes it possible to choose obedience over pride.

Maybe the most important question in your next disagreement isn’t, “How can I get my spouse to understand that I’m right?” Maybe it’s, “What would it look like for me to do what is right, right now?” Because in marriage, the goal isn’t to defeat the person you love. It is to build a life together.

And sometimes, the greatest victory begins when one person has the wisdom and humility to stop playing the game and turn it over to God.

Ready to Stop Playing the Game?

If you and your spouse have become trapped in a cycle of hurt, reaction, and retaliation, you don’t have to stay there. A healthier marriage begins when you stop trying to win against each other and start learning how to win together.

At Your Great Marriage, we help couples identify the beliefs and behaviors keeping them stuck, rebuild connection, and discover practical, biblical ways to move forward. Whether your marriage is struggling or you simply want to make a good marriage even better, we’re here to help.

Take Your Next Step:

Schedule a FREE 10-Minute Connection Call — Let’s talk about your marriage and how we can help.

Schedule a 60-Minute Marriage Assessment — Gain clarity about what’s happening in your relationship and identify practical next steps.

Explore Our Two-Day Marriage Intensive — Invest focused time in strengthening your relationship and building a healthier future together.

Visit Your Great Marriage to learn more and connect with us, email us for immediate help: Help@yourgreatmarriage.help.

There’s Still Hope.